Maryland case law › Wilson v. Boor ex rel. Hall

Wilson v. Boor ex rel. Hall

40 Md. 483 (1874) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Rev'd in partStewart, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThis action was brought to recover the amount of an award. The declaration recited the submission and award and alleged non-performance by the defendant. The defendant pleaded several pleas, including the fourth and fifth pleas, which alleged that the arbitrators appointed no time for the hearing, that the defendant had no opportunity to produce material evidence, and that the arbitrators refused to hear his proofs. The plaintiff demurred to these pleas, and the Circuit Court sustained the demurrer. On appeal, the Court of Appeals held that it would be in utter subversion of the principles of enlightened jurisprudence to allow arbitrators to disregard the vital and cardinal principle of notice and fair opportunity to be heard. The Court recognized that parties may waive notice, or the case may be of such character as not to require notice, and if the submission dispensed with notice or t
Questions presented
  • Whether the Circuit Court erred in sustaining the demurrer to the fourth and fifth pleas, which alleged that the arbitrators appointed no time for the hearing, that the defendant had no opportunity to produce material evidence, and that the arbitrators refused to hear his proofs.
  • Whether the Circuit Court erred in sustaining the demurrer to the seventh plea, which proposed to enter into the merits of the controversy between the parties and the action of the arbitrators, and relied on other grounds of defense.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Stewart, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This action was brought to recover the amount of an award. The nar. in substance, recites the submission and award, and alleges its non-performance by the defendant. To the fourth, fifth and seventh pleas of the defendant, the plaintiff demurred, and the Circuit Court sustained the demurrer, and these present the only matters for our review in this appeal.

The fourth and fifth pleas substantially allege that the arbitrators appointed no time for the hearing of the case ; and the defendant had no opportunity to produce material ■evidence; that the arbitrators, when applied to by him, refused to hear his proofs. It would be in utter subversion of the principles of enlightened jurisprudence, to hold that arbitrators selected by the parties for the determination of their disputes, have the power to disregard such a vital and cardinal principle in the administration of justice, as to undertake to discharge their duties without notice to the parties, of the hearing, and fair opportunity of trial. Such a doctrine finds no sanction in our practice. On the contrary, our Courts have recognized the absolute justice and propriety of these indispensable requisites. 489 Bullitt vs. Musgrave, 3 Gill, 49 ; Young and wife, vs. Reynolds’ Exrs., 4 Md, 375 ; Md. & Del.

R. R. Co. vs. Porter, 19 Md., 458 ; Bushey vs. Culler, 26 Md., 534 . (Decided 24th June, 1874.) Parties may waive notice, or the case may be of such character as not to require notice. If the submission, by its terms, has dispensed with notice, or the necessity of adducing testimony, of course no such defence could be made. 19 Md., 458 . The Circuit Court erred in sustaining the demurrer to the fourth and fifth pleas, and its judgment must be reversed as to them.

But as to the seventh plea, proposing to enter into the merits of the controversy between the parties, and the action of the arbitrators, and relying on other grounds of defence, we find no error in its ruling. Judgment reversed, and new trial ordered.