Maryland case law › Young v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

Young v. Warden of Maryland House of Correction

212 Md. 638 (1957) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedCollins, J.✓ Good law
SummaryThomas W. Young filed an application for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Chief Judge Emory H. Niles of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City, after a hearing. Young had been tried on charges of burglary and carrying a deadly weapon and sentenced by Judge Joseph Byrnes to four years in the Maryland House of Correction from March 20, 1955. Young contended that he pleaded not guilty but, by a mistake of the clerk, a plea of guilty was entered. At the habeas hearing, Assistant State's Attorneys Pairo and Murphy testified that their records and notations on the indictment showed guilty pleas to both charges, and they remembered him pleading guilty; certified docket entries also showed guilty pleas. Young further contended that he requested counsel and was denied. He testified to prior convictions: 1946 thirty days jail; 1948 150 days for traffic violations; 1949 a
Questions presented
  • Whether petitioner's contention that he pleaded not guilty but a plea of guilty was entered by mistake of the clerk entitles him to relief on habeas corpus.
  • Whether petitioner was denied counsel for his defense in violation of federal constitutional rights.
  • Whether petitioner was denied the right to cross-examine state witnesses, and whether that issue can be raised on habeas corpus.
  • Whether petitioner was not allowed to testify in his own defense, and whether that issue can be raised on habeas corpus.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Collins, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an application by Thomas W. Young for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus by Chief Judge Emory H. Niles, of the Supreme Bench of Baltimore City, after a hearing held before him on October 23, 1956. Petitioner was tried on charges of burglary and carrying a deadly weapon and sentenced by Judge Joseph Byrnes to four 640 years in the Maryland House of Correction from March 20, 1955. Petitioner contends that he pleaded not guilty and, by a mistake of the clerk of the court, a plea of guilty was entered at the trial before Judge Byrnes.

At the hearing on the petition held by Judge Niles, Messrs. Pairo and Murphy, Assistant State’s Attorneys, who tried the case for the State, testified that the records in the State’s Attorney’s Office and the notations which they made on the face of the indictment showed that petitioner pleaded guilty to both charges and, also, that they both remembered that he pleaded guilty. Also, certified copies of the docket entry show that petitioner pleaded guilty to both charges. Johnson v. Warden, 209 Md. 643 , 120 A. 2d 914 ; Pritchard v. Warden, 209 Md. 662 , 121 A. 2d 696 .

Petitioner further contends that he requested counsel for his defense and this request was denied by the trial judge. At the hearing before Judge Niles petitioner testified that in 1946 he was sentenced to jail for thirty days. In 1948 he served 150 days in jail for traffic violations. In 1949 he had a year’s probation for unauthorized use of an automobile.

In 1951 he served eighteen months in the Maryland House of Correction for attempted burglary. Petitioner alleges no facts which would show that any ingredient of unfairness actively operated in the trial which resulted in his confinement. He was experienced in court cases. It is well settled that the Federal Constitution does not compel a state to furnish counsel as a matter of right as is required by the 6th Amendment in federal prosecutions.

Lack of counsel at state trials denies federal constitutional protection only when the absence of counsel results in a denial of the essentials of justice to the accused. The burden of showing that want of counsel operated actively as an ingredient of unfairness is on the traverser. . There is no such evidence here. Truelove v. Warden, 207 Md. 636 , 115 A. 2d 297 .

Petitioner also alleges that he was denied the right to cross-examine state witnesses. This goes only to the regularity of the proceedings and not to the jurisdiction of the trial court 641 and cannot be raised on habeas corpus. Pritchard v. Warden, supra. Petitioner further contends that he was not allowed to testify in his own defense.

This can be raised on appeal but not on habeas corpus. Bowen v. Warden, 200 Md. 661 , 90 A. 2d 174 . Application denied, with costs.