Maryland case law › Berry's Lessee v. Willett

Berry's Lessee v. Willett

2 Md. 376 (1852) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: Other✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a Maryland ejectment action in which the plaintiff moved for judgment against the casual ejector for the undefended portion of the land—specifically, land for which the defendant had initially taken defense upon the plots returned at the prior term but had since relinquished his claim and excluded from his defense by amendment. The plaintiff also moved for full costs up to the time of the amendment. The court granted the motion in part, directing entry of judgment against the casual ejector for all lands in the declaration mentioned that were undefended by the defendant upon the plots returned. The court further ordered that the defendant pay the plaintiff his costs expended in the suit up to that term, and that if the plaintiff proceeded to trial, all subsequent costs would depend on the event of the trial. The opinion is extremely brief and does not articulate a general legal r
Questions presented
  • Whether the plaintiff is entitled to judgment against the casual ejector for the undefended part of the land, where the defendant had taken defense for that part at the prior term but had since relinquished his claim and excluded it from his defense by amendment.
  • Whether the plaintiff is entitled to full costs up to the time of the amendment, where the defendant had initially defended the land but later relinquished it.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

377 The plaintiff’s counsel at the trial, moved for judgment against the casual ejector for the undefended part, viz* such part as the defendant had first taken defence for and afterwards on amendment had relinquished and moved for full costs up to the time of making the amendment. The Court directed the following entry to be made, viz. “ Judgment against the casual ejector for all the lands in the declaration mentioned, which are undefended by the defendant upon the plots returned in this cause. “ On motion of the plaintiff by his counsel, and it appearing to the court that part of the land for which this ejectment is brought, and which is now undefended, was in the defendant’s possession at the time of bringing this ejectment, and is still in his possession, and that the defendant actually took defence for the same upon the plots returned in the cause at the last term, and hath since relinquished his claim thereto and excluded the same from his defence, as appears by the plots returned in this Court, “ It is ordered by the Court, that the defendant pay to the plaintiff his costs by him expended in this suit up to this term; and if the plaintiff proceeds to trial, that all sub* sequent costs shall depend on the event of the trial.”