Maryland case law › Bowers v. Eastern Aluminum Corp.

Bowers v. Eastern Aluminum Corp.

240 Md. 625 (1965) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: AffirmedPrescott, C. J.✓ Good law
SummaryIn May 1961, George Bowers was injured when a scaffold collapsed while he and Franklin Moyer were performing tasks 'sublet' to them by Eastern Aluminum Corporation, a home-improvement company. Bowers sought workmen's compensation from the Workmen's Compensation Commission, which awarded him temporary total disability benefits and hospital expenses. Eastern Aluminum appealed to the Baltimore City Court, which, sitting without a jury, reversed the Commission's award, finding that Bowers and Moyer were independent-contractor joint venturers, not employees of Eastern Aluminum. Bowers appealed to the Court of Appeals of Maryland. The Court of Appeals framed the issue as whether Eastern Aluminum or its sub-contractor was the employer of Bowers at the time of injury under the Workmen's Compensation Act. The Court held that the trial court's finding that Bowers and Moyer were independent contrac
Questions presented
  • Was the Eastern Aluminum Corporation, or its sub-contractor, the employer of George Bowers, claimant-appellee, at the time of the accidental injury under the terms of the Workmen's Compensation Act?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Prescott, C. J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an appeal from a decision of a judge of the Baltimore City Court, sitting without a jury, which reversed an award by the Workmen’s Compensation Commission in favor of appellant, George Bowers, compensating him for temporary total disability and hospital expenses, resulting from an injury sustained during the course of his work. In May of 1961, appellant was injured when a scaffold, upon which he was working with one Franklin Moyer, collapsed while the two were engaged in performing certain tasks “sublet” to them by appellee, a company active in the business of making home improvements. The issue presented to the Court read: “Was the Eastern Aluminum Corporation, or its sub-contractor, the employer of George Bowers, claimant-appellee, at the time of the accidental injury'under the terms of the Workmen’s Compensation Act?” The trial court answered this issue “No,” finding that at the time of Bowers’ injury, Bowers and Moyer were working on a job given them by appellee as independent-contractor joint venturers.

The appellant argues that the court was clearly in error in this finding, but further contends that even if Bowers were a partner in a joint venture at the time of his injury, he was still entitled to compensation under the Maryland statute as a “working partner.” The first portion of appellant’s contention turns entirely upon mixed questions of law and fact. Nothing will be gained if 627 we set forth in detail the evidence supporting the court’s findings of fact, and the evidence to the contrary. Suffice it to say that there was substantial direct testimony, which was confirmed in several of its aspects, to support the findings. We cannot say they were clearly erroneous, but, in fact, find ourselves in accord with them.

And we find no error in the application of the law to the facts. When this situation develops, we must affirm. Maryland Rule 886 a. Turning to the latter contention of appellant, we held above that the trial judge was justified in finding that the relationship between Bowers and Moyer and the appellee was that Bowers and Moyer were independent contractors performing work for appellee.

This is dispositive of the appeal. It is established law in Maryland that an independent contractor is not an “employee” under Code (1957), Article 101, § 67 (3). Board of Sup’rs of Elections v. Balser, 172 Md. 187 ; Williams Constr. Co. v. Bohlen, 189 Md. 576 ; Snider v. Gaultney, 218 Md. 332 .

Binding affirmed, appellant to pay the costs.