Maryland case law › Edwards v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

Edwards v. Warden of Maryland Penitentiary

221 Md. 575 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DeniedPrescott✓ Good law
SummaryEdwards filed an application for leave to appeal under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act, challenging his conviction and sentence. He alleged that officers of the Baltimore Police Department promised him leniency if he pleaded guilty, and that this promise was not fulfilled. The Court of Appeals, in a per curiam opinion delivered by Judge Prescott, denied the application. The Court held that Edwards's allegation was insufficiently specific to raise a substantial question of unfairness requiring an evidentiary inquiry. Unlike Hamilton v. Warden, where the petitioner named the officer and specified the promise, Edwards failed to identify any officer or state what was said to him. The Court noted that the term 'given leniency' is vague and largely a matter of opinion. The Court also stated that all other questions raised had been previously decided adversely to Edwards and were prop
Questions presented
  • Whether the petitioner's allegation that police officers promised him leniency if he pleaded guilty is sufficiently specific to raise a substantial question of unfairness requiring an evidentiary inquiry.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Prescott, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. The petitioner in this application for leave to appeal to this Court under the Uniform Post Conviction Procedure Act raises no question or questions that have not been previously decided by us adversely to his present contentions. All of the questions raised were properly decided by the court below, and all were amply considered except the one that follows. He claims that the “Police of Baltimore Police Department” told him that they “would see that petitioner would be given leniency if he plead guilty * * * at the time of trial.” In Hamilton v. Warden, 214 Md. 633 , Judge Henderson, for 576 the Court, said that whether such a question could be raised on habeas corpus was not free from doubt, but the circumstances of that case, where the Police Officer was named, and his alleged promise to recommend a suspended sentence specifically set out with an allegation that the Officer failed to carry out his promise, justified an inquiry into the truth or falsity of the allegation.

In the instant case, we have nothing except a bald allegation that the police officers of Baltimore City would see that he was “given leniency.” He fails to name any officer or officers or to state what they said to him. Just what the terms “given leniency” would mean in any particular case would be difficult to determine, as it would probably be largely a matter of opinion. In any event, it is certain that Edwards’ allegation is not sufficiently specific to raise a substantial question of unfair ness, which should be inquired into. Dobson v. Warden, 220 Md. 689 .

For the above reasons and those set out in the opinion of the trial judge the application will be denied. Application denied.