Maryland case law › Gardner v. Warden

Gardner v. Warden

217 Md. 653 (1958) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryThis is a per curiam opinion of the Court of Appeals of Maryland denying an application for leave to appeal from the denial of a writ of habeas corpus. The petitioner, Gardner, sought habeas corpus relief in the Baltimore City Court, challenging his conviction and ten-year sentence. Judge Byrnes denied the petition, and Gardner applied to the Court of Appeals for leave to appeal. The Court, in a brief per curiam opinion, held that the involuntary character of a confession and the insufficiency of the evidence to convict are matters reviewable on direct appeal, not on habeas corpus. The Court further held that the petitioner's claims—that he was not afforded process for witnesses and that the prosecuting witness failed to testify—affect only the regularity of the proceedings and, absent a demand for compulsory process, do not implicate the jurisdiction of the trial court. Finally, the Cou
Questions presented
  • Whether the involuntary character of a confession and the insufficiency of the evidence to convict are reviewable on habeas corpus.
  • Whether the failure to afford process for witnesses and the failure of the prosecuting witness to testify concern the jurisdiction of the trial court so as to be reviewable on habeas corpus.
  • Whether mere statements that a petitioner was held incommunicado without benefit of counsel, was put in double jeopardy, and received an unlawful sentence are sufficient allegations of fact to show a denial of constitutional rights.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

217 Md. 653 (1958) 141 A.2d 684 GARDNER v. WARDEN OF MARYLAND PENITENTIARY [H.C. No. 121, September Term, 1957.] Court of Appeals of Maryland. Decided May 27, 1958. Before BRUNE, C.J., and HENDERSON, HAMMOND, PRESCOTT and HORNEY, JJ. PER CURIAM: The application for leave to appeal is denied with costs.

Judge Byrnes properly ruled on the petition filed in the Baltimore City Court for a writ of habeas corpus that the involuntary character of a confession and the insufficiency of the evidence to convict the petitioner of "conspiracy" was reviewable on appeal but not on habeas corpus. The petitioner's claim — not passed upon by the court below — that he was not afforded process for witnesses, and the failure of the prosecuting witness to testify, affect the regularity of the proceedings and, absent a demand for compulsory process, do not concern the jurisdiction of the trial court. The mere statements by a petitioner (i) that he was held incommunicado without benefit of counsel, (ii) that he was put in double jeopardy, and (iii) that his ten-year sentence was unlawful, without more, are not sufficient allegations of fact to show a denial of constitutional rights.