Maryland case law › Turner v. Warden

Turner v. Warden

220 Md. 669 (2001) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryIn this post-conviction proceeding, the applicant sought relief on two grounds: (a) that he was not guilty of attempted armed robbery, and (b) that he was represented at trial by incompetent counsel. The court denied leave to appeal on the ineffective assistance claim, adopting the reasons stated in Judge Allen's opinion in the trial court. As to the sufficiency-of-evidence claim, the court noted that Judge Allen's opinion indicated that the only argument presented at the post-conviction hearing was ineffective assistance of counsel, suggesting that the guilt-or-innocence point was waived. Even assuming it was not waived, the court held that the question of guilt or innocence cannot be retried in a Post Conviction Procedure Act proceeding because that Act is not a substitute for a motion for a new trial or for an appeal. The court cited the applicable statute, Code (1957), Art. 27, sec.
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant should be granted relief because he was not guilty of the offense of attempted armed robbery.
  • Whether the applicant should be granted relief because he was represented at his trial by incompetent counsel.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

PER Curiam. The applicant contends that he should be granted relief because (a) he was not guilty of the offense of attempted armed robbery and (b) he was represented at his trial by incompetent counsel. The second contention was fully considered and disposed of by Judge Allen’s opinion in the trial court, and leave to appeal on that ground is denied for the reasons stated in his opinion. Judge Allen’s opinion states that the only argument for relief presented at the hearing was that the petitioner was represented [at the original trial] by incompetent counsel appointed by the court.

This suggests that the first point was waived. Even if it was not waived, it is of no avail to the applicant in this case. The question of guilt or innocence cannot be retried in Post Conviction Procedure Act proceedings, since that Act is not a substitute for a motion for a new trial 670 or for an appeal. See Code (1957), Art. 27, sec. 645A (Supp. 1959).

Cf. Bell v. Warden, 218 Md. 666 , 146 A. 2d 56 ; and Gardner v. Warden, 217 Md. 653 , 141 A. 2d 684 , certiorari denied 357 U. S. 942 ; both of which are habeas corpus cases. Application denied.