Maryland case law › Johnson v. State

Johnson v. State

423 Md. 137 (2011) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: ReversedMurphy, J. (dissenting)✓ Good law
SummaryThis case involves a criminal defendant, Petitioner Johnson, who moved for a mistrial after a juror's cellular phone battery was found to have been activated during trial, potentially exposing the jury to extraneous information. The Circuit Court denied the motion, finding no manifest necessity for a mistrial after polling the jury and receiving no indication that any juror was unable to follow the instruction to disregard anything seen or heard on the phone. The Court of Special Appeals affirmed. The Court of Appeals, in a majority opinion, reversed, holding that the trial court abused its discretion because it failed to conduct an individual voir dire of each juror to determine whether any juror had actually been exposed to extraneous information and whether that exposure was prejudicial. The dissent, authored by Judge Murphy, disagreed, arguing that the trial court had a sufficient fa
Questions presented
  • Whether the trial court abused its discretion in denying Petitioner's motion for a mistrial without conducting an individual voir dire of each juror to determine whether any juror was exposed to extraneous information and whether such exposure was prejudicial.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

MURPHY, J., dissenting. I agree with the majority that “a trial court’s discretion when to grant or deny a motion for mistrial can be properly exercised only when sufficient facts are known to the court.” I dissent, however, from the holding that the case at bar is one in which “the trial court’s denial of Petitioner’s motion for a mistrial was an abuse of discretion.” In my opinion, the Circuit Court had a sufficient factual basis for concluding that, “Having polled the jury and not having a response, I don’t find there’s manifest necessity to declare a mistrial.” 156 The record shows that, after instructing the jurors in open court that “you cannot use, directly or indirectly ... what, if anything, you saw and/or heard ... once you placed the battery in the phone and activated it,” the Circuit Court asked the jurors four questions. The first three questions asked, “Does everybody understand [the instructions]?” The fourth question asked, “Now is there anyone who is unable to comply with that instruction during deliberation? Raise your hand.” The record also shows that, when it returned its verdicts over four hours after deliberations resumed, the jury acquitted Petitioner of robbery with a dangerous weapon, first degree assault and the handgun charges relating to those offenses.

Because Petitioner’s trial counsel never requested that the Circuit Court conduct an individual voir dire of each juror, I would hold that the Circuit Court’s failure to do so was neither erroneous nor an unfairly prejudicial abuse of discretion, and would therefore affirm the judgment of the Court of Special Appeals.