Maryland case law › Simpson v. Director of Patuxent Institution

Simpson v. Director of Patuxent Institution

234 Md. 618 (1964) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: Denied✓ Good law
SummaryErnest Edwin Simpson pleaded guilty in the Criminal Court of Baltimore on May 25, 1961, to robbery and was sentenced to eight years in the House of Correction; he had been transferred to Patuxent Institution on April 5, 1961. On April 29, 1963, he filed a petition under the Post Conviction Procedure Act, raising five contentions: (1) the identifying witness was never seen by him and did not appear in court; (2) he pleaded guilty so the State would drop other charges; (3) his counsel did not argue the case; (4) he was not represented by counsel at his preliminary hearing before a magistrate; and (5) he was illegally arrested. The lower court denied relief on contentions (2), (3), and (4) for the reasons it assigned. It did not explicitly answer contentions (1) and (5), but found as facts that Simpson's privately employed counsel was widely experienced and had represented him 'fairly, prop
Questions presented
  • Whether the applicant waived his right to raise contentions that the identifying witness was never seen by him and did not appear in court, and that he was illegally arrested, by entering a free and voluntary plea of guilty.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Per Curiam. On May 25, 1961, the applicant, Ernest Edwin Simpson, was sentenced to 8 years in the House of Correction by the Criminal Court of Baltimore after pleading guilty to an indictment charging robbery, and on April 5, 1961, was transferred to the Patuxent Institution. On April 29, 1963, he fded a petition under the Post Conviction Procedure Act, alleging: (1) The identifying witness was never seen by the applicant and did not appear in court. (2) The applicant pleaded guilty so that the State would drop other charges against him.

(3) His counsel did not argue the case. (4) He was not represented by counsel in his preliminary hearing before a magistrate. (5) He was illegally arrested. For the reasons assigned by the lower court the application for leave to appeal is denied as to contentions (2), (3) and (4).

The lower court did not explicitly answer contentions (1) and (5), although it found, as facts, that the applicant’s privately employed counsel was widely experienced and had represented him “fairly, properly and adequately,” and that the applicant’s plea of guilty had been entered voluntarily and without coercion of any kind, after counsel had informed the applicant of his rights and of the consequences of a plea of guilty. Hence, the applicant waived his right to raise contentions (1) and (5), because a free and voluntary plea of guilty acts as a waiver of all nonjurisdictional defects and is a conviction of the highest order. Case v. State, 228 Md. 551; Gans v. Warden, 233 Md. 626 . In addition, the plea of guilty rendered it unnecessary for the identifying witness to appear and testify.

Biles, Jr. v. State, 230 Md. 537 . Application denied.