Maryland case law › Big Vein Coal Co. v. Leasure

Big Vein Coal Co. v. Leasure

192 Md. 435 (1949) · Court of Appeals of Maryland
Court of Appeals of MarylandDisposition: DismissedCollins, J.✓ Good law
SummaryMilson Thomas Leasure, an employee of Big Vein Coal Company, filed a workers' compensation claim (No. A47878) on July 5, 1945, for an injury to his right hand sustained on June 19, 1945. The State Industrial Accident Commission awarded him $23 per week for disability. Neither the claim nor the accompanying surgeon's report mentioned any back injury. In May 1947, Leasure petitioned to reopen the claim, alleging a back injury sustained at the same time as the hand injury. On November 14, 1947, the Commission denied compensation on the ground that the back and hip claim was barred by limitations. Leasure appealed to the Circuit Court for Allegany County. Before the appeal was heard, Leasure petitioned that court to remand the proceedings to the Commission so he could amend his claim; the State Accident Fund agreed, and the case was remanded. On April 7, 1948, the Commission granted leave to
Questions presented
  • Whether the order of the State Industrial Accident Commission granting leave to file an amended claim is an appealable final order or an interlocutory order from which no appeal lies.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Collins, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. This is an appeal by the State Accident Fund, appellant, from an order of the State Industrial Accident Commission, (the Commission), allowing Milson Thomas Leasure, claimant and appellee, an employee of Big Vein Coal Company, to file an amended claim for compensation. On July 5, 1945, appellee filed a claim, No. A47878, for an injury to his right hand, the accident occuring on June 19,1945. The Commission awarded him $23 a week during the continuance of his disability to begin on June 23, 1945.

In that claim of July 5,1945, no mention was made of any injury to any other part of appellee’s body, other than the right hand. Filed with that claim was a surgeon’s report which mentioned no injury, other than the right hand. In May, 1947, the appellee filed a petition requesting the reopening of claim No. A47878, supra, filed July 5, 1945, for the purpose of determining his disability from a back injury which he alleged he sustained at the same time he injured his right hand, the back injury not having been stated in his original claim. The Commission set 437 the case for hearing at Cumberland on August 15, 1947, on the reopening of claim No. A47878, supra.

On November 14, 1947, the Commission passed an order denying compensation on the ground that the claim for the injury to claimant’s back and hip was barred by limitations. From that order the appellee appealed to the Circuit Court for Allegany County. Before the case was heard on appeal the appellee filed a petition in that court asking that the proceedings be remanded to the Commission in order that he could amend his claim. The attorney for the State Accident Fund agreeing to the remand, the case was ordered remanded to the Commission for further proceedings.

On April 7, 1948, the Commission passed an order granting leave to the appellee to file the amended claim. From that order the State Accident Fund appealed to the Circuit Court for Allegany County. The Circuit Court for Allegany County ordered the appeal dismissed and from that order the State Accident Fund appeals to this Court. This order of the Commission allowing for claimant to amend his claim is interlocutory and not a final order at this stage of the case.

The appeal must be dismissed. It has been stated many times by this Court that no appeal can be taken here from an interlocutory order. The judgment must be final before this Court has any jurisdiction to hear the appeal. Statutory provisions for appeal from, or review of, orders of administrative tribunals have generally been construed as applicable, not to interlocutory orders, but only to final orders.

Penny v. Maryland State Police, 186 Md. 10, 12 , 45 A. 2d 741 ; Elkton Supply Co. v. Stubbiles, 180 Md. 97, 99 , 23 A. 2d 3 , and cases there cited; Leberstein v. Leberstein, 186 Md. 25 , 45 A. 2d 753 ; Snyder v. Cearfoss, 186 Md. 360, 366 , 46 A. 2d 607 ; Brann v. Mahoney, 187 Md. 89 , 48 A. 2d 605, 611 ; Katz v. Katz, 188 Md. 537, 540 , 52 A. 2d 925, 927 ; Federal Power Commission v. Metropolitan Edison Co., 304 U. S. 375 , 58 S. Ct. 963 , 82 L. Ed. 1408 . Appeal dismissed, with costs.