Maryland case law › Shober v. Cochrane

Shober v. Cochrane

53 Md. 544 (1880) · Maryland Court of Appeals
Maryland Court of AppealsDisposition: AffirmedBy the Court✓ Good law
SummaryIn Shober v. Cochrane, the Court of Appeals of Maryland was asked to issue a writ of mandamus to compel a county school board to reinstate a teacher. The Circuit Court refused the writ, and the Court of Appeals affirmed. The Court held that under the Acts of 1872, ch. 377, sub-ch. 3, sec. 4, and 1874, ch. 463, sub-ch. 3, sec. 4, the power to decide the matter in dispute was vested in the State Board of Education, and that its decision was final and conclusive. The Court relied on Wiley v. Board of County School Commissioners of Allegany County, 51 Md. 401, as dispositive of the jurisdictional question. The Court further stated that, in its opinion, the State Board of Education's decision on the merits was correct and would be affirmed if the Court had jurisdiction to review it. Judge Robinson dissented on the question of the jurisdiction of the State Board of Education. The Court's opini
Questions presented
  • Whether the power to decide the matter in dispute was vested in the State Board of Education, and whether its decision thereon was final and conclusive, thus barring the issuance of a writ of mandamus by the Circuit Court.
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

By the Court : In this case the order of the Circuit Court refusing the writ of mandamus will he affirmed ; this Court being of opinion that under the Acts of 1872, ch. 377, sub-ch. 3, sec. 4, and 1874, ch. 463, sub-ch. 3, sec. 4, the power to decide the matter in dispute, was vested in the State Board of Education, and that its decision thereon was final and conclusive. Wiley, et al. vs. Board of County School Commissioners of Allegany County, 51 Md., 401 , appears to us to dispose of this question. It may not be out of place to say, after an examination of the question, that in our opinion, the decision by the State Board of Education in this case upon the merits was correct, and if we had jurisdiction to review it, would be affirmed. Robinson, J., dissented on the question of the jurisdiction of the State Board of Education.