Maryland case law › Silverberg v. State

Silverberg v. State

35 Md. App. 222 (1977) · Maryland Court of Special Appeals
Maryland Court of Special AppealsDisposition: ReversedDavidson✓ Good law
SummaryThe State of Maryland Central Collection Unit filed a declaration in the Superior Court of Baltimore City on 23 December 1975 seeking to recover money allegedly due from E. David Silverberg, sub-committee for John Booze. The State attached a motion for summary judgment, a supporting affidavit, and a notice to plead. On 16 January 1976, Silverberg filed a motion ne recipiatur, asserting that the affidavit failed to show the affiant's competence to testify or that it was made on personal knowledge. On 15 March 1976, the trial court permitted the State to amend its affidavit and denied Silverberg's motion. The next day, 16 March 1976, the court entered final judgment for the State on the summary judgment motion. Silverberg appealed, arguing that the trial court erred by granting summary judgment before the time for filing his responsive pleading had elapsed. The Court of Special Appeals agr
Questions presented
  • Did the trial court err in granting the appellee's motion for summary judgment before the time for filing his responsive pleading had elapsed?
📖 Open the full case in RecordCite — full opinion, AI chat, highlights & citator →

Davidson, J., delivered the opinion of the Court. On 23 December 1975, in the Superior Court of Baltimore City, the appellee, State of Maryland Central Collection Unit, filed a declaration seeking to recover money allegedly due and owing from the appellant, E. David Silverberg, sub-committee for John Booze. A motion for summary judgment, a supporting affidavit apd a notice to plead were attached. On 16 January 1976, the appellant filed a motion 223 ne recipiatur alleging that the affidavit did not affirmatively show that the affiant was competent to testify or that the affidavit was made upon personal knowledge of the affiant. 1 On 15 March 1976, the trial court permitted the appellee to amend its affidavit, and denied the appellant’s motion.

On 16 March 1976, a final judgment was entered in favor of the appellee. Here, the appellant contends that the trial court erred in granting the appellee’s motion for summary judgment before the time for filing his responsive pleading had elapsed. We agree. The Maryland Rules have the force of law. 2 Maryland Rule 309 a provides: “Where a motion ... requiring a ruling by the court ... is filed, the time for pleading, including ... an answer to a motion for summary judgment or affidavit in support thereof, shall be enlarged, without special order, to fifteen days after ... disposition by the court of such motion, demurrer or exception.” (Emphasis added.) 3 Under this rule, the appellant was entitled to 15 days from the date upon which the court denied his motion ne recipiatur within which to file an answer to the appellee’s motion for summary judgment. 4 The trial court erred in entering a judgment on the motion for summary judgment before that time had elapsed.

Judgment reversed. Case remanded for further proceedings in accordance with this opinion. Costs to be paid by the appellee. . Maryland Rule 610 b. .

Hauver v. Dorsey, 228 Md. 499, 502 , 180 A. 2d 475, 476 (1962); Main v. Lynch, 54 Md. 658, 668 (1880); Moaney v. State, 28 Md. App. 408 , 414 n.4, 846 A. 2d 466 , 471 n.4 (1975). . Related rules must be read together. DuPont, Glore, Porgan, Inc. v. Barshack, 271 Md. 316, 319 , 316 A. 2d 527, 528 (1974); Baltimore Transit Co. v. Mezzanotti, 227 Md. 8, 19-20 , 174 A. 2d 768, 774 (1961). See Md. Rule 610 a 1, 2; Md. Rule 610 c 1, 3; Md. Rule 307 a 1; Md. Rule 309 a. .

See DuPont, supra, 271 Md. at 318-19 , 316 A. 2d at 528-29 .